Peggy Noonan Writes a great Article About Facebook and Zuckerberg.

DJIA Futures0.24%▲ U.S. 10 Yr2.127%▼ Euro-0.11%▼

SUBSCRIBE
SIGN IN
Search

Enter News, Quotes, Companies or Videos
Robert Massimi.
I really like this article that Peggy Noonan wrote today. She is spot on about Facebook and Mark Zuckerberg.
Facebook and Zuckerberg run there fiefdom in the Silicon Valley a d its time Zuckerberg goes and that Facebook is broken up.
Read below:
OPINION DECLARATIONS
Overthrow the Prince of Facebook
Big tech has become too powerful and abusive. We know enough about it to break up its dominance.

By Peggy Noonan
Updated June 6, 2019 7:22 p.m. ET
SHARE
TEXT
182

Mark Zuckerberg speaks in San Jose, Calif., May 1, 2018. PHOTO: MARCIO JOSE SANCHEZ/ASSOCIATED PRESS
I’ll start with a personal experience and then try to expand into Republicans and big tech.

In the spring of 2016, Facebook came under pressure, stemming from leaks by its workers, over charges of systemic political bias. I was not especially interested: a Silicon Valley company that employs thousands of young people to make decisions that are often ideological will tilt left, and conservatives must factor that in, as they’re used to doing.

My concerns about Facebook had to do with its apparently monopolistic nature, slippery ethics and algorithmic threats to serious journalism.

Soon after, I received an email from Mark Zuckerberg’s office inviting me and other “conservative activists” to attend a meeting with him to discuss the bias charges in an off-the-record conversation. I responded that I was not an activist but a columnist, for the Journal, and would be happy to attend in that capacity and on the record. That didn’t go over too well with Mr. Zuckerberg’s office! I was swiftly told that wouldn’t do.

What I most remember is that they didn’t mention where his office is. There was an air of being summoned by the prince. You know where the prince lives. In the castle. Who doesn’t know exactly where Facebook is?

In February 2018 Nicholas Thompson and Fred Vogelstein of Wired wrote a deeply reported piece that mentioned the 2016 meeting. It was called so that the company could “make a show of apologizing for its sins.” A Facebook employee who helped plan it said part of its goal—they are clever at Facebook and knew their mark!—was to get the conservatives fighting with each other. “They made sure to have libertarians who wouldn’t want to regulate the platform and partisans who would.” Another goal was to leave attendees “bored to death” by a technical presentation after Mr. Zuckerberg spoke.

Predictably, the conservatives “failed to unify in a way that was either threatening or coherent.” Many used the time “to try to figure out how they could get more followers for their own pages.”

After the meeting, attendees gushed, calling Mr. Zuckerberg and his staffers humble and open. Glenn Beck praised the CEO’s “earnest desire to ‘connect the world.’ ”

Never were pawns so happily used.

I forgot about it until last summer, when Mr. Zuckerberg’s office wrote again. His problems were mounting. I was invited now, with an unspecified group of others, to “an off the record discussion over dinner at his home in Palo Alto.” They used that greasy greaseball language Silicon Valley uses: Mr. Zuckerberg is “focused on protecting” users and thinking about “the future and how best to serve the Facebook community.”

I ignored the invitation. They pressed. Their last note reached me at an irritated moment, so I wrote back a rocket, reminding him of the previous meeting and how it had been revealed to be a mischievous and highly political enacting of faux remorse. I suggested that though it was an honor to be asked to cross a continent for the privilege of giving him my time, thought and advice, I would not. I added that I was sorry to say he strikes me in his public, and now semiprivate, presentations as an imperious twerp.

For a second I actually hesitated: The imperious twerp runs the algorithms, controls the traffic, has all the dark powers! But I am an American, and one with her Irish up, so I hit send.

And I’m still here, at least at the moment, so I guess that’s OK.

Facebook’s famous sins and failings include the abuse of private data, selling space to Russian propagandists in the 2016 presidential campaign, starving journalism of ad revenues, monopolistically acquiring or doing in possible competitors, political mischief, and turning users into the unknowing product. I once wrote the signal fact of Mr. Zuckerberg’s career is that he is supremely gifted in one area—monetizing technical ingenuity by marrying it to a canny sense of human weakness.

None of this is news. We just can’t manage to do anything about it.

Now there are moves to push back. The House Judiciary Committee will hold antitrust investigations into big tech. Speaker Nancy Pelosi is warning that “unwarranted concentrated economic power in the hands of a few is dangerous to democracy.” Sen. Elizabeth Warren has made a splash with her pushback on big tech; Sen. Amy Klobuchar included it in her presidential announcement speech.

The New York Times this week had a breakthrough report, from Cecilia Kang and Kenneth Vogel, on how the tech giants are fighting back. They are “amassing an army of lobbyists.” Facebook, Google, Amazon and Apple spent a combined $55 million in lobbying last year, about double what they spent in 2016. They “have intensified their efforts to lure lobbyists with strong connections to the White House, the regulatory agencies, and Republicans and Democrats in Congress.” Facebook hired Mrs. Pelosi’s former chief of staff. The speaker herself has received major campaign money from employees and political-action committees of all the tech giants. Google pays lobbyists who worked on the Republican staff of House Judiciary.

They’ve got it wired, haven’t they?

But the mood in America is anti-big-tech. Everyone knows they’re too powerful, too arrogant, loom too large in public life.

And something else: This whole new world of new technology was born in the 1970s and ’80s. We still think it’s new and we’re figuring it out, but we’re almost half a century into it and we can see what works and what doesn’t, what’s had good effects and hasn’t. It is time to move.

We’re Americans and we love money and success and the hallowed story of the kid in the garage who invents the beautiful product that changes the world.

And Republican officials—they can’t help it, they don’t just rightly love business; they love big business, they love titans. It’s almost romantic: Look what people can do in America! He started it in his dorm room! And now we’re at lunch!

It’s all too human, and of course greedy: Maybe these guys will start giving me money! I mean Pelosi-size money!

Here’s what they should be thinking: Break them up. Break them in two, in three; regulate them. Declare them to be what they’ve so successfully become: once a pleasure, now a utility.

It all depends on Congress, which has been too stupid to move in the past and is too stupid to move competently now. That’s what’s slowed those of us who want reform, knowing how badly they’d do it.

Yet now I find myself thinking: I don’t care. Do it incompetently, but do something.

Why are Republicans so slow to lead? The Times quoted Republican Sen. Josh Hawley as saying “the dominance of big tech” is a “big problem.” They “may be more socially powerful than the trusts of the Roosevelt era, and yet they still operate like a black box.”

He’s right.

But I read about lobbyists coming at Republican congressional leaders and I think, it’s going to be like Mr. Zuckerberg’s meeting with the conservatives in 2016. A tech god will give them some attention, some respect, and they’ll fold like a cheap suit.

If they are as stupid and unserious as their critics take them to be, they will go to the meeting and be used.

They should say no and hit send.

SHOW CONVERSATION
(182)
Join the Conversation
Fed Begins Debate on Whether to Cut Rate as Soon as JuneFed Faces Challenging Rate Decision at June Meeting How Fiat Chrysler’s Proposed Merger With Renault CrashedHow Fiat Chrysler’s Proposed Merger With Renault Crashed U.S., Mexico Make Progress on Migration Issues, but Tariffs Still LoomTrump Pressures Mexico as Second Day of Border Talks Begin The Baby Boomer vs. Millennial Investment SmackdownThe Baby Boomer Vs. Millennial Investment Smackdown JPMorgan Scraps New App Service for Young PeopleJPMorgan Closing Down Finn Digital Bank a Year After Nationwide Launch TV Broadcasters Outside Parliament Can’t Shake ‘Stop Brexit Steve’TV Broadcasters Outside Parliament Can’t Shake ‘Stop Brexit Steve’ Chamber CEO’s Rare Washington Perk: Private Jet Service, Even for VacationsChamber CEO’s Rare Washington Perk: Private Jet Service, Even for Vacations U.S. Spent Two Weeks on Edge Over Iran’s Missile BoatsU.S. Spent Two Weeks on Edge Over Iran’s Missile Boats Leaders Mark 75th Anniversary of D-DayLeaders Mark 75th Anniversary of D-Day Homelessness Grows in California Despite New Government SpendingHomelessness Grows in California Despite New Government Spending
About this article
Declarations
“Declarations” seeks the truth and then tries to state that truth. The column is published online every Thursday evening and aims to give clarity and humor where appropriate. It is isn’t overtly ideological and asks the reader to be open to different considerations.

+ Show More

Peggy Noonan
Peggy Noonan is an opinion columnist at the Wall Street Journal where her column, Declarations, has run since 2000.

She was awarded the Pulitzer Prize for Commentary in 2017. A political analyst for NBC News, she is the author of nine books on American politics, history and culture, from her most recent, “The Time of Our Lives,” to her first, “What I Saw at the Revolution.” She is one of ten historians and writers who contributed essays on the American presidency for the book, “Character Above All.” Noonan was a special assistant and speechwriter for President Ronald Reagan. In 2010 she was given the Award for Media Excellence by the living recipients of the Congressional Medal of Honor; the following year she was chosen as Columnist of the Year by The Week. She has been a fellow at Harvard University’s Institute of Politics, and has taught in the history department at Yale University.

Before entering the Reagan White House, Noonan was a producer and writer at CBS News in New York, and an adjunct professor of Journalism at New York University. She was born in Brooklyn, New York and grew up there, in Massapequa Park, Long Island, and in Rutherford, New Jersey. She is a graduate of Fairleigh Dickinson University in Rutherford. She lives in New York City. In November, 2016 she was named one of the city’s Literary Lions by the New York Public Library.

+ Show More
Learn more about WSJ Opinion here
What to Read Next…

REVIEW & OUTLOOK
Opinion | Joe Biden’s Green Free Lunch

POLITICS
Trump Expresses Concern About Gun Silencers in Wake of Virginia Shooting

TECH
Facebook Revamps Defense Team as Antitrust Scrutiny Increases

POTOMAC WATCH
Opinion | A Democrat Deflates a Trump ‘Scandal’

Independent of The Wall Street Journal newsroom
INVESTING
Hop on now before Dow reaches 40,000, says forecaster who nailed 2018 selloff

MANSION GLOBAL ARTICLE
Modern House on an Oceanfront Plot in the Hamptons With a Private Boardwalk

BOOKSHELF
Five Best: Marie Brenner on Memoirs of Moral Amnesia and Self-Justification
POPULAR ON WSJ
Most Popular Videos
[https://m.wsj.net/video/20190605/060519glossary_vix/060519glossary_vix_167x94.jpg]
Why the VIX Keeps Investors on Edge
[https://m.wsj.net/video/20190606/060619brexitguy1/060619brexitguy1_167x94.jpg]
Brexit’s Loudest Opponent Won’t Shut Up
[https://m.wsj.net/video/20190606/060619trumpddayveteransv2/060619trumpddayveteransv2_167x94.jpg]
Trump Honors D-Day Veterans at 75th Commemoration
[https://m.wsj.net/video/20190605/060519veterans4/060519veterans4_167x94.jpg]
D-Day Veterans Share Wartime Stories at the 75th Commemoration
[https://m.wsj.net/video/20190606/060619opvidpw/060619opvidpw_167x94.jpg]
Opinion: Klobuchar Speaks Truth to a Faux Trump ‘Scandal’
Most Popular Articles
Baby Boomer vs. Millennial Investment Smackdown
Baby Boomer vs. Millennial Investment Smackdown
U.S. Spent Two Weeks on Edge Over Iran’s Missile Boats
U.S. Spent Two Weeks on Edge Over Iran’s Missile Boats
It’s OK. Don’t Cook. This Approach Is Surprisingly Healthy.
More Universities Find Full-Time M.B.A. Programs Aren’t Worth It
More Universities Find Full-Time M.B.A. Programs Aren’t Worth It
Inside the Effort to Fix the Troubled Boeing 737 MAX
Inside the Effort to Fix the Troubled Boeing 737 MAX
BACK TO TOP
Edition

Facebook
Twitter
Instagram
YouTube
Podcasts
Snapchat
WSJ Membership Benefits
Customer Center
Legal Policies
Google Play
Robert Massimi
Diw Jones
Associated press
Bing
@bing
Twitter
@Twitter
Medium.com
Gothamreview.nyc/wp
Mark Zuckerberg
Facebook
Google
Apple
Amazon
Jeff Bezos
Drudge report
Judicial watch
Fiefdom
Tony award’s
Silicon valley
Alga rythm

Author: nobullwithragingrobert

Was a drama critic at Manhattan College. Wrote professionally for Bergen News, Sun Bulletin . Alpha Sigma Lambda, Beta Theta. Has seen over 600 shows worldwide, has published both on Theater and Politics. Avid reader on many subjects and writers. Chief Drama critic for Metropolitan magazine. Writes for Jerrick media, American conservative, The City Journal and Reason magazine. Has produced shows both on and off Broadway.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s